Shelter Island Heights, New York

About Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights is a small unincorporated community in southeastern New York.

Shelter Island Heights holds the status of a census-designated place — a real, named community that residents call home, governed at the county level. The community covers 5.4 square miles.

📰 Shelter Island Heights News Today

• Shelter Island Heights Air Quality Index (AQI) and USA Air Pollution IQAir · Jun 22
• Krakoffs Set Shelter Island Record With $15.96 Million Purchase of Iconic Jaffe Home 27east · Jun 2
• Modern Shelter Island Home Seeks $200K Summer Rental Behind The Hedges · Apr 23
• Shelter Island: Where Tides Converge Inhabit by Corcoran · Nov 10
• Arrest warrant issued for Isola owner: Failed to appear in court on liquor license charges Shelter Island Reporter · Jun 10

Live headlines via Google News — updates through the day.

What Makes Shelter Island Heights Unique

• The only place in America named Shelter Island Heights — a truly one-of-a-kind name among 32,000+ US communities.
• An unincorporated community — no city hall of its own, which often means lower local taxes and county-managed services.
• Positioned in southeastern New York, convenient to the region's corridors and crossings.

Why People Love It Here

• A tight community feel that bigger cities can't replicate.
• Cost of living typically runs below the big-metro average.
• Well connected: 3+ neighboring communities within 4 miles.

📍 Neighborhoods in Shelter Island Heights

Click a neighborhood to see it on the map.

🍽️ Where to Eat in Shelter Island Heights

• 18 Bay — new american
• Salt
• Sunset Beach
• Commander Cody's

Local spots mapped by the OpenStreetMap community.

🏞️ Parks & Outdoors in Shelter Island Heights

• Cedar Beach County Park reviews ★

Parks mapped by the OpenStreetMap community · "reviews" opens each park's live Google reviews.

⚡ Quick Facts

🗺️ Map of Shelter Island Heights

🏘️ Nearby Communities